What Makes a Book “Good” or “Bad”?

A Discussion on Personal Taste vs. Writing Quality

Let’s be real—everyone has that one book they hated but someone else couldn’t stop raving about. Maybe it was a book with two pages of worldbuilding for every sentence of dialogue, or maybe the plot twist was so obvious you saw it coming five chapters ago. Or maybe—just maybe—the book was beautifully written, well-structured, and… just not your thing.

So what actually makes a book good or bad? Is it all personal preference, or are there real markers of quality? Let’s break it down.

Personal Taste: The Wild Card

Personal taste is the most unpredictable part of the equation. It’s like pizza toppings—some people love pineapple on pizza, while others think it’s a crime against humanity. Books work the same way.

Some readers crave fast-paced action. Others love slow-burn character studies. Some want poetic, flowery prose. Others want a writing style so straightforward it feels like a text message. A book can be well-written in a technical sense but still bore someone to tears because it just doesn’t click with them.

Examples of Personal Taste in Action:

📖 You love witty, sarcastic narrators? A book like Percy Jackson might be a favorite. Hate them? It might be unbearable.

📖 You need romance in every story? A book with zero romance might feel flat—even if the plot is solid.

📖 You prefer books with deep themes and serious discussions? A fluffy rom-com might seem shallow to you, but to someone else, it’s the perfect comfort read.

Bottom line: A book can be “bad” to you but still be a masterpiece to someone else.

Writing Quality: The Foundation

Now, writing quality is where things get a little more objective. Even if personal taste is subjective, there are things that generally make a book stronger or weaker.

Signs of Good Writing Quality:

✅ Strong Characters – Characters should feel like real people, not cardboard cutouts with one personality trait. Even villains should have depth.

✅ A Cohesive Plot – A good story should have a sense of direction. If things happen just because with no real cause-and-effect, the plot falls apart.

✅ Engaging Pacing – Even slow-burn stories should keep readers hooked. If you’re slogging through endless pages waiting for something to happen, pacing might be off.

✅ Well-Developed Themes – Even fun, lighthearted books tend to have something deeper at their core. It could be about friendship, resilience, or finding yourself, but it shouldn’t feel like a jumbled mess.

Signs of Weak Writing Quality:

❌ Flat or Inconsistent Characters – If a character makes choices that don’t align with their personality, it’s frustrating. No one wants a “strong female lead” who suddenly forgets how to stand up for herself because the plot demands it.

❌ Plot Holes and Convenience – If the hero wins just because of luck (or the villain suddenly forgets how to use their powers at the worst moment), that’s lazy storytelling.

❌ Excessive Info-Dumping – Yes, we love worldbuilding. No, we don’t need five pages explaining the history of a fictional currency when the protagonist is running for their life.

❌ Unpolished Writing – Awkward dialogue, clunky sentences, or overly complicated prose can make a book hard to enjoy, no matter how great the story is.

When Personal Taste and Writing Quality Collide

Sometimes, a book is both well-written and unappealing to you. You might appreciate the skill behind it but still not enjoy the experience.

Example: You recognize Pride and Prejudice as a beautifully crafted classic, but the slow pace and old-fashioned language just don’t work for you. That’s totally valid! It doesn’t mean the book is bad—just that it’s not your cup of tea.

On the flip side, some books are riddled with plot holes or awkward writing but still beloved because they’re fun. Maybe they have compelling characters or a plot so wild you can’t stop turning the pages.

Example: Plenty of readers criticize Twilight for its writing, but millions of people love the romance and the atmosphere. A book can be flawed but still enjoyable.

The Verdict? Good and Bad Are Not Always Clear-Cut

At the end of the day, books aren’t math equations. A “bad” book for one person might be a life-changing read for another. That’s the beauty of storytelling—it’s subjective, messy, and deeply personal.

So the next time someone loves a book you hate (or vice versa), just remember: it’s all about taste and perspective. And if you find that book—the one that makes you stay up all night because you have to know what happens next—hold onto it. Because for you, that book is good.

And that’s all that really matters.

---

Want me to tweak anything? Or do you want a different kind of post next? 😊